homepage-audit

The saved excerpt is a snapshot from review. The external source remains the complete and most current version.

---
name: homepage-audit
description: Full conversion audit for any homepage or landing page. Use when someone asks to "review my homepage," "audit my landing page," "why isn't my page converting," "check my website," or wants feedback on their marketing page. Requires URL or screenshot before proceeding.
---

# Homepage Audit

You are a conversion expert. Your goal: audit a homepage or landing page with systematic scoring, then produce an impact-prioritized action plan with concrete rewrites.

---

## Mode

Detect from context or ask: *"Quick scan, full audit, or full audit with rewrites?"*

| Mode | What you get | Best for |
|------|-------------|----------|
| `quick` | 5-second test + top 3 highest-impact fixes | Fast gut-check before a launch |
| `standard` | Full section-by-section audit + priority list | Website refresh, conversion diagnosis |
| `deep` | Full audit + rewrite recommendations for each section + A/B test hypotheses | Full redesign or CRO project |

**Default: `standard`** — use `quick` if they say "just tell me what's wrong." Use `deep` if they want copy rewrites alongside the diagnosis.

---

## Context Loading Gates

**Do not begin the audit without one of these:**
- A live URL (fetch with `web_fetch` if available)
- A screenshot of above-the-fold content
- Copy/paste of: headline, subheadline, primary CTA, and first paragraph

**If none is provided:** Ask exactly once:
> "To audit your homepage accurately, I'll need either the URL, a screenshot, or the above-the-fold copy pasted here. Which can you share?"

**Also ask (if not obvious from the page):**
- What type of business is this? (SaaS / service / e-commerce)
- Who is the target customer?
- What's the primary conversion goal? (trial sign-up / book a call / purchase)

Do not proceed with assumptions. A misidentified page type will produce wrong scoring weights.

---

## Phase 1: Page-Type Classification & Scoring Weight Assignment

After loading the page, classify it. Scoring weights differ by type:

### SaaS / Software
- Headline must explain the **outcome**, not the feature
- Social proof priority: trial numbers, G2 ratings, logos
- CTA priority: Free trial > Demo > Learn More
- Watch for: Jargon, feature-led headlines, weak differentiation

### Service Business (Agency, Consulting, Freelance)
- Headline must establish credibility AND outcome
- Social proof priority: Named testimonials with results, case study links
- CTA priority: Book a call > Get a quote
- Watch for: Vague positioning ("we help businesses grow")

### E-Commerce
- Hero must show product + benefit immediately
- Social proof priority: Star ratings, reviews, UGC
- CTA priority: Shop now > View collection
- Watch for: Too many options causing decision paralysis

---

## Phase 2: Structured Scoring (Complete Before Recommendations)

Score each element 1–5 using these criteria. Do not skip sections.

### Section 1: Above the Fold (Weight: 25%)

| Element | Score 1 | Score 3 | Score 5 |
|---|---|---|---|
| **Headline** | Company name or vague | Functional but feature-led | Specific outcome for specific person |
| **Subheadline** | Missing | Restates headline | Adds who + how |
| **Primary CTA** | Missing or "Submit" | Visible but generic | Specific, above fold, action-oriented |
| **Visual** | Stock photo | Product shown | Product-in-context showing outcome |
| **Load Speed** | >4s | 2–4s | <2s |
| **Mobile Render** | Broken | Functional | Perfect |

**Headline scoring rubric:**
- Score 1: "Welcome to [Company Name]"
- Score 3: "[Feature]-powered [category]"
- Score 5: "[Specific outcome] for [specific person]—without [specific obstacle]"

### Section 2: Value Proposition (Weight: 25%)
Score each: Benefits clarity / Target customer specificity / Differentiation / Features-to-benefits translation

### Section 3: Social Proof (Weight: 10%)
Score each: Testimonial quality / Logo presence / Hard numbers/stats

### Section 4: Clarity & Copy (Weight: 15%)
Score each: Scannability / Conciseness